Educause Horizon report 2024

This year's EDUCAUSE horizon report on teaching and learning DUCAUSE horizon report on teaching and learning is now out. 

The report follows the structure of the previous reports. Trends are derived through a series of scans which encompass social, technological, economic, environmental and political trends. In this edition, AI is added as a honorary trend.

Key technologies revolve around AI, the need to support equitable and inclusive learning, practice data privacy and security, the targeting of misinformation and supporting mental health. In this, there is a move towards viewing technology as both enabler and supporter along with ensuring the importance of ethics, equity and inclusiveness.

The scenarios presented are representative of the North American higher education contexts and not all of these are easily generalisable into other national frameworks or experiences. However, the horizon report is always useful in providing information on what may happen next. The report provides updates on the affordances availed by technology and it is up to educational institutes to consider their own challenges and to interpret the report's findings and recommendations towards their own localised contexts. 

Food and Fibre COVE - new approach to learner pathways

The Food and Fibre CoVE(Centre for Vocational Education Excellence) and the Workforce Development Council - Muka Tangata -   have developed a new skills framework for their sector. Both Muka Tangata and the CoVE supports industries across agriculture, horticulture, seafood and Veterinary services. 

The project's website also provides links to the framwork, the research report (prepared by Kathryn Koopmanschap and Dr. Nicky Murray), and the recommendation paper. 

The framework is informed by an analysis to various international frameworks and alignment with the Aotearoa NZ context. The work arose from the need to recognise the skills many people bring into the industry so that they can fast track through the industry-specific qualifications. 

The framework components include core transferable skills, core technical skills, industry-specific skills and bodies of knowledge. 

All in, a step in the right direction to help provision qualifications that are industry-led, easily understood by industry and learners, flexible, transferable and with the ability to bridge both formal and informal learning. 

Resources for AI - course for higher education and assessment ideas

Two good resources to support the integration of AI into learning and teaching.

Firstly, a resource for higher education, hosted by Tilburg University (the Netherlands). The course introduces Gen AI and LLMs, discusses the opportunities and covers limitations and ethics, helps educators evaluate the influence of Gen AI on course design, evaluate the impact of Gen AI on assessments and encourages modification where necessary and identifies various ways educators and students can use AI in a responsible manner.

Participants are advised that the course will take around 2 hours and is user friendly. There are short video clips to explain some concepts, an overview statement at the end of each module, and a self-check quiz.

The second resource is from the UK it is a slide deck, which offers assessment ideas for an AI enabled world. Various ideas are offered with background and suggestions for how they may be incorporated in to higher education. The 'cards' are opportunities for further discussion amongst colleagues with encouragement to customise the cards for use by individual faculties to mirror disciplinary influences and frameworks.

He Ruku Hohonu - supporting Mōari apprentice carpenters

Unable to attend the synchronous presentation of He Ruku Hohonu, held at the end of March. Instead, the efficient organisers provided access to a recording. The presentation is well worth watching as it provides a good example of rangahau (Maaori research approaches) and contributes much to a better understanding of how to meet the needs of all learners.

This project is a partnership between ConCove Tūhura and Te Kōrari Rangahau, Tui Bradbrook, Susan Luke and Jamie Ihimaera Smiler and has been funded by the ConCove Project Fund. The report can be found here along with the literature review. 

The recording of a presentation is archived on YouTube. 

The research draws on the small corpus of work undertaken in the last 2 decades - many funded through either Ako Aotearoa or through the ex-industry training organisations (ITOs). For construction-related industries research funding has been provided through the BCITO.

The research is important. Statistics are worrying for Maaori - in 2018, 2,455 began apprenticeships. By 2022, there were 584 successful completions, 601 were still engaged but 1296 had left the industry.

The literature review looked through 65 articles published in the last 15years and categorised them into 3 groups - whakamana (39), whakakaha (18) and whakaihihi (8). 15 of the most relevant were summarised and the 65 articles synthesised with 9 kaupapa (themes) identified. Of note is the need for sector capability with capacity constraints and that current interventions which are not specifically designed to support Maaori, perform poorly for Maaori.

Interview data was gathered from students, teachers, iwi, whanau (family) and kaiwhakawhihi mahi (assessors).

Kaupapa Maaori theory analysis underpinned analyst. Tino rangatiratanga (self determination), Taonga tuku iho (cultural aspirations, ako Maaori (culturally preferred pedagogies), Kis piki ake (socioeconomic mediation), Whaanau (extended family support) and Kaupapa (collective philosophy). 

Findings for each theme from each group of interviewees were shared.

Recommendations included: celebrating aakonga success; clarifying pathways for continuing education; strengthening kanohi ke te kanohi (f2f( delivery; integrating marae infrastructure into support and delivery; communicating better with whanau; establishing peer support infrastructure; establishing a clear timeline for tracking progression; increasing access to academic learning support; and providing comprehensive mentoring and wrap-around support.

Going forward, the challenge is how these recommendations and findings can be enacted. 

Handbook of AI at work - book overview

This book is edited by M. Garcia-Murillo, I. MacInnes and A. Renda. It is published by ElgarONline at the beginning of 2024. 

The book has 18 chapters, organised into 3 parts. An introduction by the editors provides a good overview of AI, its historical development and its implications to human labour. 

The first part has 4 chapters on the theme of 'conceptualising the human with the machine'. The main discussion in this section is on the interrelationships and interactions between humans and machine with a strong message about the importance of aligning machine potential and human values.

The second part has 10 chapters, each providing a case study or a specialised application of AI into work. Industries include agriculture, manufacturing, construction and civil engineering, home-based care of the aged, professional learning, entrepreneurial finance, creative industries, judicial systems, national security and governance and policy making.

The last section has 3 chapters discussing ' the labour implications of AI at work'. 

All in, a good overview of how AI impacts on work, the 'guardrails' that need to be in place to ensure ethical integration of AI into work, and examples of the reach of AI across industries.

Theory of practice architecture - book overview

 This book,  the theory of practice architecture is by Peter Grootenboer and Christine Edwards-Groves. It is published by Springer in 2023.

Being a book in the Springer Brief series, it has five chapters. The first chapter summarises the premises with regards to the concepts of practice architetcture as a research approach to help understand real-world practices and 'practice-scapes.

The second chapter, extends the work into the wider approach of theories of ecologies of practice.

Then the third chapter explains the importance of situating practices into their authentic settings.

Chapter four details the ways practice architecture influence and lead the interpretation and analysis of data.

The last chapter provides recommendaitions on how to disseminate practice-based research to ensure it has impact and is used tranformationally to inform and perhaps enhance practice.

Creating the university of the future - book overview

 This 2024 open access book, Creating the university of the future is published by Springer and edited by U-D Ehlers and L. Eigbrecht. It is part of the book series on Future Higher Education. 

There are 30 chapters, organised into five sections.

The editors 'Set the scene' with 3 chapters in the first section - Creating the university of the future: A global panorama on future skills; towards a future skills framework for higher education; and the practice of future skills learning: an assessment of approaches, conditions and sucesss factors.

The next section focuses on 'future skills- foundations and shapes of a new emerging concept in a global view. There are six chapters in this section. 

Then 11 chapters in the section on future skills in practice - teaching and learning. The chapters provide case studies or examples of contemporary pedagogy from across the world.

The fourth section is on 'future skills in practice - assessment'. with 4 chapters. Emphasis is placed on formative assessments across the chapters.

The last section has a series of chapters from various countries which have worked towards achieving 'future skills'. Chapters are on the 'skills future movement in Singapore'; 'continuing education at the National University of Singapore'; Educational digital transformation of university education in Japan; future IT skills; and further higher education in New Zealand.

Overall, a good collection of chapters, some philosophical/theoretical but many reporting on current approaches. 

Peformance based research funding in Aotearoa New Zealand -

 Last week, the Tertiary Education Commission (TEC) announced that the University Advisory Group, has been tasked with reviewing the mechanism for recognition and funding of research in tertiary institutions. The Performance-based Research Funding (PBRF) is the main conduit for the funding of research at universities and polytechnics 

Taking this into account, the current collation of evidence towards the 2018-2026 evaluation round, has been cancelled. The Tertiary Education Union (TEU) have always contended that the PBRF system was unwieldy and expensive, taking up much of academics' time without any real benefits for them. 

What happens next, will hopefully be more manageable and fair. Across three posts, Roger Smyth has discussed some possibilities. Firstly, he overviews the system as it stands and summarises the inherent challenges. Then, he presents some possible solutions. A postscript was then added providing examples of how the possible solutions proposed, may play out. Of note is that PBRF is a funding regime that is derived from the university sectors' research volume. Smaller tertiary providers in the form of  Wananga (Māori Universities) and Polytechnics which participate in research as they offer degree level and above qualifications, will always have much smaller volumes of research outputs. Therefore, their share of the PBRF, has always been much smaller. 

The recommendations from the University Advisory Group on PBRF will therefore, always be a balancing act between how funding drives research activity and the costs of measuring the quantity and quality of the activity. The current system is very costly, in terms of time, for individual institutions and individual researchers. Hopefully, a better, more efficient method is presented that does not penalise non-university research. 

Māori voices in the AI landscape

 Dr. Karaitiana Taiuru maintains a blog and also posts on linkedin. He is an authority on IT issues and ther effects on Māori. His blog has posts on Māori data sovereignty AI/data and emerging technologies and critical indigenous research.

This linkedin post discusses the small number of Māori active in the technology sector in Aotearoa NZ and how this needs to change as many aspects of AI have far and long reaching effects on all people. Ensuring larger Māori representation in the digital space, is important to ensure their voices are heard. 

References provide a good resource.

Prompt engineering - Claude prompt library and other resources

 Prompt engineering is part of AI literacies and as interaction with Gen AI platforms/tools/apps increases, the competency to be able to effectively use prompt engineering has increased.

A theoretical approach to prompt engineering is offered by this IBM video whereby the approaches are based on computer science principles or algorithms.

For educational and pedagogical approaches, the paper by Mollick & Mollick (2023) recommends the assignation of a role to AI, usually as a coach/mentor. The role undertaken by AI, guides the types and tone of conversation with the AI. 

Good examples can now be found through the Claude AI prompt library. There are dozens of prompts to get things started for work, study and leisure tasks. These are useful in education as examples that can be deconstructed by learners, for them to work out the main principles for prompt engineering. 

Alternatives to ChatGPT

 A list of free and paid alternatives to ChatGPT can be found at Writesonic's site which compares each alternative to its own Chatsonic. 

Another list is found at Clickup which also compares the alternatives with both ChatGPT and its own project - Clickup.

More neutral recommendations from analyticsvidhya blog,  PC world and an older one (2023) from TechRadar for free to try alternatives.

Each has advantages and disadvantages and some have been adopted by certain industries as 'standards' or 'go to' platforms. Not all provide the ability to 'build your own chatbot' so it will be interesting to see how many are still about next year and of those that survive, how many provide additional features. 

Learning Design Voices -

 Learning Design Voices captures the perspecitves of learning designers post-pandemic. The book is open access and edited by South African learning designers/researchers T.Jaffer, S.C. Govender and L. Czerniewicz. 

After an introduction, the book has three sections (provocations).

The first provocation is 'what might learning design become in the post-COVID university? has five chapters. Each cover one of several themes -

1) increased visibility and value of learning designers due to the need to shift to flexible delivery models.

2) open learning design - on the margins

3) learning designer as pedagogical advisor

4) learning how to design learning through mimicry and mentoring

5) indigenous learning practices

The second focuses on compassionate learning design for unsettling times, with six chapters. The chapters focus on issues of equity, access, humanising learning, inclusivity and community.

The final provocation ' the challenge of designing experiences' has 13 chapters. Here, various examples, case studies and reflective studies are presented.

14) adapting ABC learning design

15) Using Laurillard's learning types

16) Rapid development prototype model

17) blended learning

18) elearning tools

19) knowledge-identity nexus

20) learner centred learning

21) authentic learning design

22) developing critique and argument

23) rethinking the textbook

24) digital divide and accessibility to print-based learning

25) ten principles of alternative assessment

26) reimagining authentic online assessments for large classes

27) inclusive online assessment

All in, may relevant chapters to inform the work of learning designers. 

Practical pedagogy

 Book published in 2019 by Routledge. Mike Sharple's draws on the innovative pedagogy series published yearly by the Open University since 2012.

The book 'Practical pedagogy'  works through the various pedagogies sorted into 6 categories. 

- Personalisation includes adaptive teaching, spaced learning, personal inquiry, stealth assessments and translanguage.

- Connectivity introduces crossover learning, seamless learning, incidental learning, learning from gaming, geo-learning, learning through social media, and navigating knowledge.

-Reflection summarises 'explore first' teachback, learning through argumentation, computational thinking, learning from animations, learning to learn. assessment for learning and formative analytics.

- Extension has threshold concepts, learning through storytelling, learning through wonder, learning in remote science labs, context-based learning, event-based learning, and learning for the future.

- Embodiment includes embodied learning, immersive learning, maker culture, bricolage, and design thinking.

- Scale refers to massive open social learning, crowd learning, citizen inquiry, rhizomatic learning, reputation management, open pedagogy, humanistic knowledge-building and communities. Some discussion of the contents of the book found here.

The last chapter discusses 'pedagogies in practice'.

Modes of learning - Mark Nichols

 An early morning webinar with Dr. Mark Nichols hosted by the Commonwealth of Learning.  on the topic of 'modes of learning'.  

Began with what is 'teaching'? Pedagogy is the dance between pedagogy and the dynamic operating decisions of the university' - teaching is the activity that gives a subject its voice, that brings the subject alive for the learner to form a relationship with. Not all teaching has to have an identifiable teacher. 

How about learning 'learning is 'a smudge between a self that knows to be self that knows more' to learn, then is to be personally smudged from one state of knowing into another ... as knowers we are forever incomplete: there is always more to know.

Introduced the project. Work with Dr. Seelig to try to look at what constituted learning, especially what is open, flexible and distance learning. For Te Pūkenga there are three modes, on-the-job, f2f, and distance delivery. What do these mean, how can they be combined, are these actually singular in themselves?

There is no such thing as an on-the-job delivery mode, turns out to be fluid. Similar to distance delivery, there are many modes as well. There is great potential in missing the modes. 

Important to consider how to meet learner needs, increase accessibility.

Q & A followed

Defining modes helps to enable common dialogue and scalable innovation. Asserts for example that peer relationships across learners are not necessarily a requirement for effective learning. Being able to define the modes help with decision-making, shared practice and strategic planning. A shared programme may not all be offered in a fixed mode but be flexible to allow for learner needs, circumstances and objectives. Defining modes enables education by design. 

Overviewed the asynchronous (most to least) OFDL distance, work-based, study centre, negotiate) and synchronous (most to least) live classroom, virtual class, flexible, local group, road show, supervised self-paced. Details in https://tinyurl.com/teachingmodes

Provided two examples, one in business to show the ways the modes can be mixed to provide flexibility for learners. Learning activity - what learners do, teaching activity - what do teachers do, resources - what academic support, subject representation, courseware, timetable - asynchrous/synchronous and assessment - enduring assessments tasks and also pre-determined, must be decided on to design the learning. 

The work on modes of learning was undertaken to inform Te Pūkenga as it brought together diverse delivery modes. However, with the disestablishment of Te Pūkenga, this work has not been taken further. 

The work is helpful though to try to place some rigor into how delivery modes are difined. Encouraged the use of these modes of learning and to help with further investigation to refined the modes, identify exemplars and explore the planning dynamics (costs, operating considerations). Challenged us to reflect on - education is always designed 'how deliberate is it?

Leaders and Legends Online learning - Professor Mike Sharples

 Dr. Mark Nichols' podcast on Leaders and Legends of Online Learning this week is with Professor Emeritus Mike Sharples. 

Began with an overview of his career, how it started with a degree in computer science and worked towards his PhD on cognition, computers and creative writing. He has always worked with AI and Gen AI for over 50 years. 

He compared the 'sudden awareness' of AI to how the internet developed. Much work undertaken over many decades before user relevance and other parts supporting the concept, took it into the mainstream. As with the www, important to think through implications and have guardrails with AI as there are many ways it can be utilised for good and also for bad.

Discussed his involvement across the 2000s with mobile learning as a means to provide more personal and individualised learning. 

Then provided an overview of how the UK version of MOOC - futurelearn - was set up to bring in good practice and pedagogy based on understanding of neuroscience into the design of futurelearn. A successful learning platform, distinctively difference from other MOOCs which are based mainly on lectures. In contrast, futurelearn stresses social learning opportunities along with the usual online learning platform mechanics.

Then introduced his most recent books including Story Machines: How computers have become creative writers.

Discussed the importance of social constructivist learning. Personalised learning is one piece but not the only one. There is still a need for learners to interact with their peers, teachers etc. to springboard and synthesise, discuss and defend their stance, weight up and evaluate their conceptual understanding. AI should not be only a technological tool but needs to be led by pedagogy. Encouraged the need to ensure the use of technology is more human centred. 

Summarised the important components of a new online system. Pedagogy is essential. Concepts include the need to have spaced learning, ensure learning is a social process, feedback is provided at the right time,and the need to build learner efficacy. AI-enhanced collaborative learning must be the goal.

Proposed the most important research is to find out how to best leverage technology to encourage and support social learning, rather than just go down the personalised learning route. New methods of assessment also need to be considered to allow for social learning and to focus on assessments for learning. Some ideas include peer assessments, the opportunity for learners to express their judgment, and evaluative and critical thinking. 

Now he is retired, his research interest centres around the future of technology-enhanced education. He is able to concentrate on research without the distractions of the other aspects of an academic career. Recommended to follow the work of colleagues at the University of Sussex and Looi Chee Kit (Nanyang Technological University and The Educational University of Hong Kong) who has had success introducing many principles of learning sciences at the primary school level. 

Unpicking Te Pūkenga - commentary on what is happening and what may work

 Roger Smyth  has had a long association with Aotearoa NZ tertiary education and his occasional blogs  provide viewpoints from his background as a policy analyst. He draws from both his experiences, scholarly work and his networks, to provide commentary on contemporary issues affecting tertiary education.

His latest blog, discusses a 'where to next' with regards to Te Pūkenga' as the process of its disestablishment begins. He summarises the reasons for the formation of Te Pūkenga, as a solution to the challenging financial position almost all of the country's polytechnics faced before merger. Discussion is had on the many facets of the reform of vocational education (RoVE) and the problems with combining the two arms of VET, the polytechnics with the industry training organisations (ITO).

He then discusses a few options for the creation of a network of regional polytechnics, how to try to bring some synergy between the objectives of polytechnics and the work-based support provided by ITOs, what do do with the funding system, and how to ensure employer and industry representations on skill needs is carried through to the standards setting function, currently held by Work Development Councils (WDCs).

It will be interesting to see how prescient some of his suggestions are, given that to date, little information has been available on what the post-Te Pūkenga landscape might look like going into the future. 

Sociomaterial design: Bounding technologies in practice - book overview

The book - Sociomaterial-Design edited by P. Bjorn and C. Osterlund was published in 2014 by Springer. 

There are 9 chapters, including the first chapter which introduces the concepts of sociomateriality and design.

The precepts of sociomateriality are argued to be useful in better understanding complex interactions. Design is brought in as to how processes are developed, and planned, initially impact on how people and things interrelate and interact. Therefore there are connections and commonalities between the two. How sociomateriality is affected by design and in turn feeds back on the efficacy of design, is a basis for better understanding intricate human associations, reactions and responses. 

5 chapters follow the introduction, reporting on a project (the emergency department in a hospital) and using it as a way to further illustrate the principles of how sociomateriality impinges on work. The last three chapters bring the various threads together with a chapter specifically on 'boundaries' and how actions affect these, how the findings can be applied to contexts beyond the healthcare sector and the overall implications on the discipline.

The concepts are now even more relevant as humans and machines' interactions and even the intertwining of the two into 'enhanced' entities become reality. 

AI tools for instructional designers

 The number of Gen AI supported apps/tools available is increasing rapidly. Here is a list from the eLearning Coach of recommendations for instructional designers. Many of these are also useful for teachers and learners.

The tools are organised into categories of animation, audio enhancement or improvement, audio text-to-speech tools, chatbot builders, classroom instruction, content search and generation, course creation, image editing, meeting apps (record, transcribe, summarise etc.), presentations, productivity, scholarly research, translation, video, and writing. 

In all, a good collation, showing the versatility of Gen AI incorporation into many tools that already existed but now 'enhanced'. 

ILO reports - Towards lifelong learning and skills for the future of work: global lessons from innovative apprenticeships AND promoting apprenticeships to meet the needs of the digital and knowledge economy

 Two recent reports from the International Labour Organisation (ILO) of relevance to future skills, digital skills and the role of apprenticeships.

Firstly, A report titled 'Towards lifelong learning and skills for the future of work: Global lessons from innovative apprenticeships"published in 2022 and authored/edited by McCoshan, A, and Markowitsch, J. with several chapters based on a collection of reports written by other authors. Most of the discussions centre around 'formal' apprenticeships. The first 4 chapters cover future skills needs including digital and green economy. There are two chapters on increasing apprenticeship participation. Then two chapters on emerging approaches to increase work-based learning including strengthening work-based learning in VET institutions and adapting apprenticeships to support the reskilling and upskilling of adults. a couple of chapters discuss how to make apprenticeship systems more flexible, inclusive and digital. The report closes with policy messages for the future of apprenticeships.

Secondly, with relevance to digital skills is the report on "Promoting apprenticeships to meet the skills needs of the digital and knowledge economy" authored by Perryman, S. and published in 2022. The report is part of the ILO Apprenticeship Development for Lifelong Learning and Training (ADULT) project.

The report overviews the effects of the digital and knowledge economy on jobs - including aspects of labour market polarisation and types of future work (platform-based, hybridisation of work and skills, pandemic effects, importance of targeted education and training); summarises the skills needs of digital and knowledge economies; discusses how apprenticeships may meet some of the challenges; provides some recommendations to meet strategic and policy, curriculum, accreditation, inclusion and funding/delivery challenges; and closes with a case study. 

Overall, both reports summarise some of the key future skills needs and postulates how apprenticeships may be modified to meet the oncoming and rapid changes in work. Mostly macro discussion with some ideas for implementation at the micro level. 

Digital Skills Framework - for Aotearoa NZ - a discussion paper

 A discussion paper commissioned by Ako Aotearoa and written by Dr. Anne Alkema provides a timely piece of work from which our 'AI in foundation studies' project can draw from. Digital skills are prerequisites to being able to make use of AI tools/apps as presently, all are reliant on text input - although users could dictate the prompts into speech to text if the relevant plugins were enabled. 

The paper discusses the various definitions of digital literacy and skills and overviews several examples from overseas (UK, Australia, Canada, Ireland, EU, US of A) to inform the development of an Aotearoa NZ version. 

Recommends 4 options - align with the current adult learning progressions (which is what we currently have at Ara); develop an essential skills framework; develop a standalone digital skills framework; and work with potential partners.